Ministers Defeated at a
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Date | Name | Office | Constituency |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1905 (5/4) | G.W.E. Loder | Lord Commissioner of the Treasury | Brighton |
| 1906 | F. Freeman-Thomas | Lord Commissioner of the Treasury | Hastings |
| 1908 (23/4) | W.L.S. Churchill | President of the Board of Trade | Manchester, North-West |
| 1910 (J) | F.D. Acland | Financial Secretary to the War Office | Yorkshire (North Riding), Richmond |
| Sir H. Norman | Assistant Postmaster-General | Wolverhampton, South | |
| J.A. Pease | Parliamentary Secretary to the Treasury | Essex, Northern | |
| 1910 (D) | C.E. Mallet | Financial Secretary to the War Office | Plymouth |
| O. Partington | Lord Commissioner of the Treasury | Derbyshire, High Peak | |
| 1911 (22/12) | A.M. Anderson | Solicitor-General for Scotland | Ayrshire, Northern |
| 1912 (5/3) | Sir A.A. Haworth, Bt. | Lord Commissioner of the Treasury | Manchester, South |
| 1914 (19/2) | C.F.G. Masterman | Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster | Bethnal Green, South West |
| 1914 (23/5) | C.F.G. Masterman | Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster | Ipswich |
| 1921 (3/3) | Sir A.S.T. Griffith-Boscawen | Minister of Agriculture and Fisheries | Dudley |
| 1922 (25/7) | T.A. Lewis | Lord Commissioner of the Treasury | Glamorganshire, Pontypridd |
| 1922 | Sir A.S.T. Griffith-Boscawen | Minister of Health | Somerset, Taunton |
| J.W. Hills | Financial Secretary to the Treasury | Durham | |
| J. Kidd | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Health, Scottish Office | Linlithgowshire | |
| Hon. G.F. Stanley | Parliamentary Under-Secretary to the Home Office | Preston | |
| W. Watson | Lord Advocate | Galloway | |
| L.O. Wilson | Parliamentary Secretary to the Treasury | Westminster, St. Georges | |
| 1923 (3/3) | Sir A.S.T. Griffith-Boscawen | Minister of Health | Surrey, Mitcham |
| Hon. G.F. Stanley | Parliamentary Under-Secretary to the Home Office | Willesden, East | |
| 1923 (6/3) | J.W. Hills | Financial Secretary to the Treasury | Liverpool, Edge Hill |
| 1923 | A.B. Boyd-Carpenter | Paymaster-General | Bradford, North |
| J.C.C. Davidson | Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster | Hertfordshire, Hemel Hempstead | |
| W.E. Elliott | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Health, Scotland | Lanarkshire, Lanark | |
| P.J. Ford | Lord Commissioner of the Treasury | Edinburgh, North | |
| Sir C.A. Montague-Barlow | Minister of Labour | Salford, South | |
| Sir R.A. Sanders, Bt. | Minister of Agriculture and Fisheries | Somerset, Bridgwater | |
| W. Watson | Lord Advocate | Carlisle | |
| 1924 | Miss M.G. Bondfield | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Labour | Northampton |
| F. Hodges | Civil Lord of the Admiralty | Staffordshire, Lichfield | |
| F.W. Jowett | Minister of Works | Bradford, East | |
| W. Leach | Under Secretary of State, Ministry of Air | Bradford, Central | |
| J.W. Muir | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Pensions | Glasgow, Maryhill | |
| R. Richards | Under-Secretary of State, India Office | Denbighshire, Wrexham | |
| E. Shinwell | Parliamentary Secretary (Mines) to the Board of Trade | Linlithgowshire | |
| W.R. Smith | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries | Norwich | |
| 1929 | A. Duff Cooper | Financial Secretary to the War Office | Oldham |
| Sir W. Cope, Bt. | Comptroller of His Majesty’s Household | Glamorganshire, Llandaff and Barry | |
| C.M. Headlam | Parliamentary and Financial Secretary to the Admiralty | Durham, Barnard Castle | |
| Sir V.L. Henderson | Under-Secretary of State, Home Office | Bootle | |
| Sir T.W.H. Inskip | Attorney-General | Bristol, Central | |
| W.G. Normand | Solicitor-General for Scotland | Edinburgh, West | |
| Sir A.H.D.R. Steel-Maitland | Minister of Labour | Birmingham, Erdington | |
| H.G. Williams | Parliamentary Secretary to the Board of Trade | Reading | |
| 1931 | A.E. Glassey | Lord Commissioner of the Treasury | Dorset, Eastern |
| M. Gray | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Labour | Bedfordshire, Mid | |
| Sir W.A. Jowitt | Attorney-General | Combined English Universities | |
| E.D. Simon | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Health | Cornwall, Penryn and Falmouth | |
| 1935 | J.R. Macdonald | Lord President of the Privy Council | Durham, Seaham |
| M.J. Macdonald | Secretary of State for the Colonies | Nottinghamshire, Bassetlaw | |
| 1945 | L.C.M.S. Amery | Secretary of State for India and Burma | Birmingham, Sparkbrook |
| W.J. Anstruther-Grey | Assistant Postmaster-General | Lanarkshire, Northern | |
| B. Bracken | First Lord of the Admiralty | Paddington, North | |
| A.E. Brown | Minister of Aircraft Production | Leith | |
| R.A. Cary | Lord Commissioner of the Treasury | Eccles | |
| Mrs. T. Cazalet-Keir | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Education | Islington, East | |
| A. Chapman | Parliamentary Secretary to the Scottish Office | Lanarkshire, Rutherglen | |
| Lord Dunglass | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Foreign Office | Lanarkshire, Lanark | |
| P.V. Emrys-Evans | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Dominions Office | Derbyshire, Southern | |
| Sir P.J. Grigg | Secretary of State for War | Cardiff, East | |
| L. Hore-Belisha | Minister of National Insurance | Plymouth, Devonport | |
| Sir A.U.M. Hudson, Bt. | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Fuel and Power | Hackney, North | |
| Mrs. F. Horsbrugh | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Food | Dundee | |
| H.W. Kerr | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Health | Oldham | |
| R.K. Law | Minister of Education | Kingston-upon-Hull, South West | |
| J.J. Llewellin | Minister of Food | Middlesex, Uxbridge | |
| G.W. Lloyd | Minister of Information | Birmingham, Ladywood | |
| W. Mabane | Minister of State, Foreign Office | Huddersfield | |
| M.S. McCorquodale | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Labour and National Service | Yorkshire (West Riding), Sowerby | |
| M.H. Macmillan | Secretary of State for Air | Stockton-on-Tees | |
| C.U. Peat | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of National Insurance | Darlington | |
| W.R.D. Perkins | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Civil Aviation | Gloucestershire, Stroud | |
| M. Petherick | Financial Secretary to the War Office | Cornwall, Penryn and Falmouth | |
| R.A. Pilkington | Civil Lord of the Admiralty | Lancashire, Widnes | |
| E.D. Sandys | Minister of Works | Lambeth, Norwood | |
| R.D. Scott | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries | Northumberland, Wansbeck | |
| Sir D.B. Somervell | Secretary of State for Home Affairs | Cheshire, Crewe | |
| G.S. Summers | Parliamentary Secretary (Overseas Trade) to the Board of Trade | Northampton | |
| G.E.P. Thorneycroft | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of War Transport | Staffordshire, Stafford | |
| A.R.L.F. Tree | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Town and Country Planning | Leicestershire, Harborough | |
| C. Waterhouse | Parliamentary Secretary to the Board of Trade | Leicester, South | |
| Sir W.J. Womersley | Minister of Pensions | Grimsby | |
| 1950 | L.J. Edwards | Parliamentary Secretary, Board of Trade | Blackburn, West |
| A.C. Jones | Secretary of State for the Colonies | Yorkshire (West Riding), Shipley | |
| E.M. King | Parliamentary Secretary, Ministry of Town and Country Planning | Poole | |
| C.P. Mayhew | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Foreign Office | Norfolk, South | |
| D.R. Rees-Williams | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Colonies Office | Croydon, West | |
| Sir F. Soskice | Solicitor-General | Bebington | |
| T. Steele | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of National Insurance | Lanarkshire, Lanark | |
| 1951 | A.M. Crawley | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Ministry of Air | Buckinghamshire, Buckingham |
| D.R. Hardman | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Education | Darlington | |
| 1959 | J.N. Browne | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Scottish Office | Glasgow, Craigton |
| Sir I.M. Horobin | Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Power | Oldham, East | |
| 1964 | A.P.L. Barber | Minister of Health | Doncaster |
| J.R. Bevins | Postmaster-General | Liverpool, Toxteth | |
| A. Green | Financial Secretary to the Treasury | Preston, South | |
| M.A. Hamilton | Lord Commissioner of the Treasury | Northamptonshire, Wellingborough | |
| P.M. Kirk | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Ministry of Defence | Kent, Gravesend | |
| M.V. Macmillan | Economic Secretary to the Treasury | Halifax | |
| A.G.F. Rippon | Minister of Public Building and Works | Norwich, South | |
| 1965 (21/1) | P.C. Gordon Walker | Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs | Leyton |
| 1970 | T.G. Boston | Assistant Whip | Kent, Faversham |
| E.A. Davies | Parliamentary Secretary, Ministry of Technology | Lancashire, Stretford | |
| J. Diamond | Chief Secretary to the Treasury | Gloucester | |
| R.F.H. Dobson | Assistant Whip | Bristol, North East | |
| Mrs. G.P. Dunwoody | Parliamentary Secretary to the Board of Trade | Exeter | |
| Dr. J.E.O. Dunwoody | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health and Social Security | Cornwall, Falmouth and Camborne | |
| D.H. Ennals | Minister of State, Department of Health and Social Security | Kent, Dover | |
| I.L. Evans | Comptroller of Her Majesty’s Household | Birmingham, Yardley | |
| G.T. Fowler | Minister of State, Department of Education and Science | Shropshire, The Wrekin | |
| Miss J. Lee | Minister of State for the Arts, Department of Education and Science | Staffordshire, Cannock | |
| D.E.T. Luard | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Foreign and Commonwealth Office | Oxford | |
| A.J. Murray | Parliamentary Secretary, Ministry of Transport | Kent, Gravesend | |
| E. Rowlands | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Welsh Office | Cardiff, North | |
| B.C.G. Whitaker | Parliamentary Secretary, Ministry of Overseas Development | Hampstead | |
| 1974 (F) | G.T.C. Campbell | Secretary of State for Scotland | Moray and Nairn |
| R.A. Hicks | Assistant Whip | Cornwall, Bodmin | |
| N.P. Scott | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Employment of Productivity | City of Westminster, Paddington | |
| H.K. Speed | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of the Environment | Warwickshire, Meriden | |
| 1979 | A. Bates | Lord Commissioner of the Treasury | Bebington and Ellesmere Port |
| E.S. Bishop | Minister of State, Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food | Nottinghamshire, Newark | |
| R.J. Carter | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Northern Ireland Office | Birmingham, Northfield | |
| B. Davies | Assistant Whip | Enfield, Enfield North | |
| Miss M.M. Jackson | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Education and Science | Lincoln | |
| F.A. Judd | Minister of State, Foreign and Commonwealth Office | Portsmouth, North | |
| D.E.T. Luard | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Foreign and Commonwealth Office | Oxford | |
| W.G. Price | Parliamentary Secretary, Privy Council Office | Warwickshire, Rugby | |
| J.E. Tomlinson | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Foreign and Commonwealth Office | Warwickshire, Meriden | |
| Mrs. S.V.T.B. Williams | Secretary of State for Education and Science | Hertfordshire, Hertford and Stevenage | |
| 1983 | J.H.N. Gray | Minister of State, Department of Energy | Highland, Ross, Cromarty and Skye |
| I.M. Sproat | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Trade | Borders, Roxburgh and Berwickshire | |
| 1987 | Earl of Ancram | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Scottish Office | Edinburgh, South |
| P.L. Fraser | Solicitor-General for Scotland | Tayside, Angus East | |
| J.J. MacKay | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Scottish Office | Strathclyde, Argyll and Bute | |
| P.G. Malone | Assistant Whip | Aberdeen, South | |
| M.N.F. Robinson | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Welsh Office | Gwent, Newport West | |
| 1992 | N.J. Bennett | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Welsh Office | Dyfed, Pembroke |
| Mrs. L. Chalker | Minister of State (Minister for Overseas Development), Foreign and Commonwealth Office | Wallasey | |
| C.R. Chope | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Transport | Southampton, Itchen | |
| M.C. Fallon | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Education and Science | Darlington | |
| J.C. Maples | Economic Secretary to the Treasury | Lewisham, Lewisham West | |
| Hon. F.A.A. Maude | Financial Secretary to the Treasury | Warwickshire, North Warwickshire | |
| Hon. C.B. Moynihan | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Energy | Lewisham, Lewisham East | |
| C.F. Patten | Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster | Avon, Bath | |
| D.A. Trippier | Minister of State (Minister for the Environment), Department of the Environment | Rossendale and Darwen | |
| 1997 | M.W. Bates | Paymaster General, Office of Public Service | Cleveland, Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland |
| Sir N.C. Bonsor, Bt. | Minister of State, Foreign and Commonwealth Office | Havering, Upminster | |
| J.C. Bowis | Minister of State (Minister for Transport in London), Department of Transport | Wandsworth, Battersea | |
| G.D. Brandreth | Lord Commissioner of the Treasury | Cheshire, City of Chester | |
| A.J.H. Burt | Minister of State (Minister for Social Security and Disabled People), Department of Social Security | Bury, North | |
| M.H.M. Carrington | Assistant Whip | Hammersmith and Fulham, Hammersmith and Fulham | |
| S.N. Coe | Assistant Whip | Cornwall, Falmouth and Camborne | |
| A.M.V. Coombs | Assistant Whip | Hereford and Worcester, Wyre Forest | |
| P.B. Cullen | Solicitor-General for Scotland | Strathclyde, Eastwood | |
| Lord James A. Douglas-Hamilton | Minister of State, Scottish Office | Edinburgh, West | |
| J.P. Evans | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Welsh Office | Powys, Brecon and Radnor | |
| R.K. Evans | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Social Security | Gwent, Monmouth | |
| M.B. Forsyth | Secretary of State for Scotland | Central, Stirling | |
| R.N. Freeman | Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster | Northamptonshire, Kettering | |
| J.J. Hanley | Minister of State, Foreign and Commonwealth Office | Richmond-upon-Thames, Richmond Park | |
| G.H. Jones | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Welsh Office | Cardiff, North | |
| R.B. Jones | Minister of State (Minister for Construction, Planning and Energy Efficiency), Department of the Environment | Hertfordshire, Hemel Hempstead | |
| T.J.R. Kirkhope | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Home Office | Leeds, North East | |
| R.M. Knapman | Lord Commissioner of the Treasury | Gloucestershire, Stroud | |
| Mrs. A.A. Knight | Economic Secretary to the Treasury | Derbyshire, Erewash | |
| G. Knight | Minister of State (Minister for Industry), Department of Trade and Industry | Derby, North | |
| G.A.B. Kynoch | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Scottish Office | Grampian, West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine | |
| Mrs. J.A.H. Lait | Assistant Whip | East Sussex, Hastings and Rye | |
| I.B. Lang | President of the Board of Trade | Dumfries and Galloway, Galloway and Upper Nithsdale | |
| P.G. Malone | Minister of State, Department of Health | Hampshire, Winchester* | |
| A.J.B. Mitchell | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Social Security | Nottinghamshire, Gedling | |
| A.H. Newton | Lord President of the Council | Essex, Braintree | |
| Hon. P.A.C.L. Oppenheim | Exchequer Secretary to the Treasury | Derbyshire, Amber Valley | |
| M.D.X. Portillo | Secretary of State for Defence | Enfield, Enfield Southgate | |
| M.L. Rifkind | Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs | Edinburgh, Pentlands | |
| R.S. Robertson | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Scottish Office | Aberdeen, South | |
| Hon. T.G. Sackville | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Home Office | Greater Manchester, Bolton West | |
| Sir D.H. Spencer | Solicitor-General | Brighton, Pavilion | |
| I.M. Sproat | Minister of State, Department of National Heritage | Essex, Harwich | |
| R.C. Squire | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Education and Employment | Havering, Hornchurch | |
| W.A. Waldegrave | Chief Secretary to the Treasury | Bristol, West | |
| J.A. Watts | Minister of State (Minister for Railways and Roads), Department of Transport | Reading East | |
| T.J.R. Wood | Comptroller of Her Majesty’s Household | Hertfordshire, Stevenage | |
| 2001 | D.A. Lock | Parliamentary Secretary to the Lord Chancellor’s Department | Hereford and Worcester, Wyre Forest |
| 2005 | Miss M.J. Johnson | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health | Hertfordshire, Welywn Hatfield |
| C.M. Leslie | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Constitutional Affairs | West Yorkshire, Shipley | |
| C.R. Pond | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Work and Pensions | Kent, Gravesham | |
| S. Twigg | Minister of State, Department for Education and Skills | Enfield, Enfield Southgate | |